DVD - Dolby 5.1 / Mono Learn more
Enter a zip code
FOR PARENTS
Standard version; Dolby Digital: English 2.0; French mono; English subtitles; Interactive menus; Scene selection; Theatrical trailer; Commentary with George Stevens Jr., production assistant and son of the late director/producer George Stevens, and Ivan Moffat, associate producer
Full Product DetailsSide #1 --
0. Scene Selections
1. Call Me Shane. [:06]
2. An Elegant Dinner. [1:27]
3. Store-Bought Clothes. [5:47]
4. A New Sodbuster. [6:59]
5. Homesteaders. [7:33]
6. Fists Fly At Grafton's. [:47]
7. Slick Wilson. [2:32]
8. A Gun Is A Tool. [3:44]
9. Independence Day. [6:21]
10. I'm A Fair Man. [1:35]
11. Stonewall. [6:59]
12. Cemetery Hill. [4:14]
13. Stacked Deck. [1:52]
14. No Match For Wilson. [2:16]
15. A Lowdown Yankee Liar. [5:43]
16. Come Back Shane. [2:24]
Often described as the "perfect" western, Shane simultaneously reaffirms and transcends genre conventions. This 1953 film's basic premise -- the violent struggle between greedy cattlemen and intrepid homesteaders -- is as old as the horse opera itself and is depicted by director George Stevens in stark, unambiguous fashion. The characters, too, are familiar types: the courageous farmer (played by Van Heflin), the dutiful wife (Jean Arthur), the hired killer (Jack Palance), and so on. Shane himself, played with admirable understatement by Alan Ladd, is positively archetypal. A former gunfighter, he seeks his redemption by helping the homesteaders, only to find them in desperate need of his "professional" skills -- the use of which, he realizes, will make him an outcast. Under Stevens's masterful direction, and bolstered by the Oscar-winning cinematography of Loyal Griggs and Victor Young's evocative musical scoring, every cliché seems fresh and every emotion rings true -- an achievement that ensures Shane a permanent place in the pantheon of great westerns. Ed Hulse, Barnes & Noble
More reviews and recommendations
Whisky galore in a cowboy saloon, with Shane significantly humiliated, abused, and told he's not a "man" when he orders non-alcoholic stuff. Other characters get notably drunk.
Fistfights and shootings, many of the bullets turning out to be fatal. Director Stevens, a WWII veteran, was determined to keep the gunplay realistic -- not gory, but not harmless and cartoony either.
Only the modest indication that Mrs. Starrett is attracted to Shane.
Not an issue.
Based on a popular (and equally fine) novel.
About Shane
Parents need to know that this is a serious-minded Western, not one of the charming but silly singing-cowboy fantasies that stampeded by the hundreds out of old Hollywood. Death is a serious thing here, and gunplay is realistic, not cartoonish or gratuitous. There's also a sense of the harshness of frontier life. The possibility of an adulterous love triangle is present but tastefully handled. Some viewers may be more troubled by the hints of Hollywood's longstanding Gone With the Wind sentimental representation of the Confederate South (the movie takes place shortly after the Civil War), or the equating of drinking whiskey with being a "real man."
Families can talk about how the characters seem unable to escape their social roles. Though it's not spelled out in detail, Shane is a veteran gunfighter trying to put his violent past behind him, but he winds up pulled back into killing, even if he is supposedly defending innocent people. Even the villains seem to be offering a last-minute compromise solution, which is declined. Did the conflict have to turn out the way it did? What do you think would have happened if Shane stayed with the Starretts?