A Phenomenal Let-Downby Anonymous
Reader Rating:
See Detailed Ratings
June 17, 2007:
My grandmother and I are both ardent lovers of Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre, and we purchased this adaptation of the novel and watched it together, as my grandmother remembered seeing it and enjoying it some years earlier. However, upon watching it, both of us were most severely disappointed. To say nothing of the film quality itself, Brontë's story and characters are decimated in this adaptation. Many important plot points are left out or unreasonably altered, and Susannah Yorke's Jane Eyre is nothing like the Jane I know and love from the novel. Yorke's Jane seems cynical and jaded, less interested in her love for Rochester than in advancing a feminist agenda that far exaggerates the undertones in Brontë's book. And while George C. Scott obviously had a great deal of potential in the role of Rochester, this adaptation leaves him no room to fulfill it. Rather than the intense, passionate, and terse Rochester of the novel, Scott's rendering of the character fails even to be convincingly grouchy for much of the film. Jane and Rochester seem more or less indifferent to one another much of the time, and two of the story's most important scenes--the confrontation between Jane and Rochester before she leaves him and the moment when he, blind and crippled, asks her again to be his wife--are conspicuously lacking in emotion and intensity. Scott and Yorke have no chemistry whatsoever, and thus many of the events of the story--and indeed the very attraction of their characters--are not believable in the least. If seeing this film had any value for me, it was only to satisfy curiosity and for the sake of watching another adaptation of Jane Eyre, but I was highly disappointed with this rendering of the story and the characters. I can think of no phrase more apt to describe this adaptation than one borrowed from Charlotte Brontë herself: "Devoid of sentiment."
This review was written about the DVD edition.
Needs A better DVD!by Anonymous
Reader Rating:
See Detailed Ratings
November 12, 2005:
I love watching the Jane Eyre movie adapations. This movie stars Suzannah York as Jane and George C. Scott as Rochester and he is a superb actor but unfortunately this movie hasn't gotten good treatment on DVD. Not only does the picture quality seem to not be good but apparently it's not even the whole movie and has been edited from it's original version. Hopefully someone will put out a better DVD! By the way: George C. Scott's co-star was Suzannah York not Sarah Miles!
This review was written about the DVD edition.